The pros and cons of using free services on the internet
Free isn't bad, and I use plenty of free software myself. The useful question is how a service pays its bills, because the answer tells you what it will do with your data and whether it will still be there in five years.

Updated November 2026.
Let me say this up front, since I run a company that charges for things: I’m not here to tell you that free is bad. I use free software every day. The services we sell are built on it.
What I’d like to do is give you a better question to ask. Not “is it free?” but “how does it pay its bills?” Because every service has bills (servers, electricity, people), and the answer to that question tells you most of what you need to know.
As far as I can tell, there are three kinds of free.
1. Free, paid for by advertising
This is the big one: search, social media, video, most free email. You pay nothing, and the company makes its money by showing you ads. The better it knows you, the more those ads are worth. So it’s in the company’s interest to learn as much about you as it can.
You don’t have to take my word for how far that goes. In September 2024 the US Federal Trade Commission published a staff report on some of the largest social media and video streaming companies. Its finding was that they “engaged in vast surveillance of consumers in order to monetize their personal information,” and that they could “indefinitely retain troves of data, including information from data brokers.”
That doesn’t make these services useless. Many of them are superbly made. It does mean the saying is true: when you aren’t the customer, your attention and your data are what’s being sold to the customer.
2. Free, as a sample of something paid
A free plan with limits, and a paid plan without them. Two gigabytes of storage free, more if you pay. Three projects free, unlimited if you pay.
This is an honest arrangement, and I like it. The paying customers cover the cost of the free ones, and the company’s income depends on making a product people want to pay for.
The thing to watch is that the free plan exists to serve the paid plan, and its terms can change. Limits get tightened. Features move to the paid side. That’s the company’s right, but it’s worth knowing before you build your life on the free tier.
3. Free, as in freedom
This is open-source software: programs whose code is published for anyone to read, use and improve. They’re paid for by donations, by volunteers’ time, or by companies that sell hosting and support around them.
This is the kind our own services are built on. Vaultwarden (password management) and Nextcloud (files) are both open source, and both are free for anyone to download and run.
So what’s the catch? Someone has to run it. A server, updates, security patches, and a person who notices when something breaks at 2 am. If you have the skills and the time, that someone can be you. I’ve been running my family’s email on my own server since 2018, so I know both the satisfaction and the chores. If you don’t, you pay someone to do it. Either way, the software is free and the running of it isn’t.
The other cost: free things get switched off
There’s one more thing about free services that has nothing to do with privacy. When you aren’t paying, you have very little say in whether the service continues to exist.
Google is the best-known example, because its shutdowns make the news. Google Reader, which a lot of people used every day to follow news and blogs, was retired on July 1, 2013. The consumer version of Google+ was shut down on April 2, 2019. Google Podcasts was discontinued in 2024.
To be fair, paid services close too. But a paying customer usually gets notice, a way to export, and a company with a reason to keep them happy.
Five questions before you sign up
You don’t need to read the whole terms of service (who does?). These five will get you most of the way.
- How does this company make money? If you can’t work it out in a minute, assume it’s from your data.
- What would I lose if it shut down next year? Photos? Ten years of email? Nothing much?
- Can I get my data out? Look for an export or download option before you put anything in.
- Is there a paid plan? That’s a good sign. It means there’s a business here that doesn’t depend entirely on ads.
- Am I putting anything in here I wouldn’t hand to a stranger? Tax returns, medical records, the kids’ photos, client files. This is where it’s worth being choosy.
So where does that leave us?
Use free things. I do. A free weather app knowing which city you’re in is not worth losing sleep over.
But for the few things that would really hurt to lose or to have read by someone else (your email, your passwords, your documents, your photos), it’s worth choosing on purpose. That might mean paying a company whose only income is from customers like you. It might mean running open-source software yourself. Both are good answers.
And yes, I’m biased, since that first option describes what we do with our managed services. But you now know how we pay our bills, which was the whole point of this post.
Cheers,
Jay