Do I need a password manager?
Short answer, yes. Longer answer, here is what one actually does for you, where the catches are, and why the free one already in your browser is a fine place to start.

Updated November 2026.
Short answer: yes.
I could stop there, but you’d be right to ask why, and what the catch is. So let’s go through it properly, the good and the not so good, and you can make up your own mind.
First, what is it?
A password manager is a locked notebook for your passwords that lives on your phone and computer. You unlock it with one password (the master password), and it does three things for you:
- It remembers every password you have.
- It makes up new ones that are long and random.
- It types them in for you when you log in.
That’s the whole idea. You remember one password, and it remembers the rest.
The problem it solves
Be honest with me for a moment. How many different passwords do you really use? If you’re like most of us, it’s three or four, with small variations. A number on the end. An exclamation mark when the website insists.
I don’t blame you one bit. No one can remember a hundred different passwords, and no one should have to.
But here’s what goes wrong. Websites get broken into all the time, and when one does, the list of email addresses and passwords gets passed around. Criminals then take that list and try each pair on other websites: the banks, the email providers, the shops. If the password for your long-forgotten forum account is also the password for your email, they’re in.
The fix is simple to say and impossible to do by memory: a different password for every account. CISA, the US government’s cybersecurity agency, puts it in one line: “Use a different strong password for each account.” And in the very same piece of advice they recommend a password manager to do it, because with one, “we only need to remember one strong password—the one for the password manager itself.”
What else you get
It notices fake websites. This one is underrated. A password manager offers your login only when the website’s address matches the one you saved. A lookalike site with one letter changed doesn’t match, so your password manager stays quiet. If you’re staring at what looks like your bank’s login page and nothing is being offered, that’s your cue to stop and look at the address bar. A tired human gets fooled by a good fake. Software comparing two addresses doesn’t.
It makes better passwords than you or I can. Long and random beats clever every time. You don’t have to think of them and you never have to type them.
It’s quicker. Really. One click or one keyboard shortcut and you’re logged in. After a week you’ll wonder how you put up with the old way.
It gives you a sane way to share. The streaming account, the utility company login, the shared work accounts. Sharing them through a password manager beats texting them around, where they sit in someone’s message history forever.
It holds more than passwords. Most of them can also keep the six-digit login codes that many sites ask for, and passkeys (the newer way of logging in with no password at all).
The catches
It wouldn’t be fair to give you only the good half.
All your eggs are in one basket. This is the obvious worry, and it’s a reasonable one. The answer is in how a good password manager is built: your passwords are encrypted on your own device, with your master password, before they go anywhere. The company storing them holds a scrambled blob it can’t read. So the basket is a very strong one. You make it stronger by choosing a long master password and turning on two-step login for the password manager itself.
If you forget the master password, that can be the end of it. This is the other side of “the company can’t read it.” If they can’t read your passwords, they can’t reset your master password either. It’s the one password you really do have to look after.
It takes an evening to set up. Installing the apps, importing what your browser has saved, getting used to the new way of logging in. It isn’t hard, but it isn’t nothing, and I won’t pretend otherwise.
Some cost money. And some don’t. Which brings me to…
Which one?
Honestly? Any reputable one is a big step up from reusing passwords. The password manager built into your browser or your phone is free, it’s already there, and it’s a perfectly good place to start. CISA says the same: “Some are free, like the built-in password managers in your web browser, and some cost money.”
A dedicated password manager earns its keep when you want the same passwords in every browser and on every device regardless of who made it, when you want to share logins with family or a team, or when you’d like your passwords kept separate from your Google or Apple account.
We run one, called Secrets. It’s built on open-source software and works with the official Bitwarden apps. Of course I think it’s good, I run it. But if this post gets you to use the free one in your browser tomorrow, I’ll count that as a win.
“But I only have a few accounts”
That’s what everyone says! Try counting. Email, bank, credit card, phone company, electricity, the pharmacy, the airline, the tax software, the kids’ school, every shop you’ve ever ordered from. You’ll run out of fingers (and toes) sooner than you think.
Where to start
Don’t try to fix everything in one weekend. Pick a password manager, put your email password in it first (your email is where every other account sends its “forgot my password” link, so it’s the one that matters most), then your bank. After that, each time you log in somewhere, take one extra minute to let the password manager replace that site’s old password with a new random one.
A few months from now the important ones will be done, and you’ll have barely noticed doing it.
Got a question I didn’t answer? Write to me. I’m happy to help, whether or not you ever become a customer.
Cheers,
Jay